Tuesday, 2 October 2012

Online Privacy - Myth or Fact?



Traditional media forms, such as television, radio and newspapers are a ‘one to many’ form of communication (Marshall, 2006). That is, the networks decide what issues are important to broadcast, and the public takes a relatively passive role. However, with the introduction of new media (such as the internet), the public now decide for themselves what is important, so much so, that it is the audience who produce the media (Marshall, 2006).

Although people have always created a version of themselves for public viewing (just look at former President John. F. Kennedy, on the outside a trustworthy, conservative man, on the inside, well, many transgressions with the opposite sex), Marshall (2010) contends that the importance of the ‘public persona’ has increased, due to the ‘many to many’ nature of new media. This has directed a trend for individuals to display one’s self online, in a very, public way (Marshall, 2006).

With the introduction of social networking sites such as Facebook, people can communicate their interests, family, pets, political views and such in a seemingly ‘safe’ environment (privacy disclaimers seem to make people more reassured regarding their information).  The power that individuals have to illustrate a version of themselves to an ever expanding audience has caused many privacy issues (Marshall, 2010).

McCreary (2008) contends that privacy is the possession of one’s own facts. I would like to add to this definition, it is not only the possession of identity information but also the control of it. What is at the core of this notion of privacy is the digitisation of information (Kachhi & Link, 2009). Now, people can access information about individuals much more prolifically than previously seen, thanks to technology. This can lead to the reconstruction of information (Marshall, 2006). For example; if a simple name and address of a person was handwritten, then it would be extremely difficult to change this information and get away with it. You would have to be an expert forger, and have the exact ink and paper as the original document. Now let’s look at the digitisation of the name and address. I can find the exact font used, there are no ‘original’ materials and I can upload my change with relative ease. This ‘method’ is widely used in the tabloid industry, were editors change photos of celebrities, to make a more sensationalist story (Marshall, 2006).

Although Jenifer Lopez may be upset by this, what are the implications for you or me?

First let’s look at Facebook – a social networking site that most students in Australia have heard of.


Debatin et al (2009) mention that the prominence of Facebook in a student’s life can lead to the site becoming so regularly used, that the process of logging on can become ‘invisible’ – and that this unrealised trust in Facebook can lead to unintended consequences such as addiction, threats to privacy and to even lose the boundary between your ‘private life’ and your ‘public’ life.

During a research survey Debatin et al, (2009) meet a young man named Peter. His privacy story started with a private argument with a ‘friend’ on Facebook, and subsequently the ‘friend’ posted the entire conversation on his Facebook account. Peter was unable to delete the upload or change it.  So, the lesson of this story is: one must be aware of the value to privacy to you and the value it is placed on by other users. However, interestingly, most student place the positives associated with Facebook way ahead of the potential privacy issues caused by using the networking site (Debatin et al, 2009).

You may be thinking: “just restrict your profile to ‘friends’ only”. Well, you are just putting a Band-Aid on a broken leg. Firstly, many people ‘friend’ individuals who they only know through a third-person (Debatin et al, 2009). Are they really your friend? Do you trust them? But let’s face it, even if your ‘friends’ only include immediate family, you are still at risk. Once your information is digitally online, as previously mentioned, it is very easy to change.

“Privacy is not a fixed value. It evolves under pressure from new technologies, shifting social priorities, and changes in generational norms of reticence and risk taking” McCreary, 2008, p 124.

It has been well established that younger adults lack a complete understanding of risk and the consequences of it (McCreary, 2008). So, regarding privacy, young adults who post information about themselves seem to value privacy as a given factor – or fail to see any consequence. Take, for example, the recent ‘sexting’ epidemic.


 Along with posting provocative pictures and believing that they will be only for restrictive viewing, young adults also seem to believe in their receivers’ discretion, regarding possessing such pictures.

However, not only is the deliberate sending of information subject to creating controversy, but also anything you do in public could…

 In The Future of Reputation: Gossip Rumour, and Privacy on the Internet, a book written by Daniel Solove, it begins by telling an amusing anecdote regarding a young lady, who refused to pick up her dog’s ‘leavings’ on a subway train, in South Korea (McCreary (2008). As a result of a bystander taking her photo, and uploading it to the internet, she became so ashamed of her cyber-created nickname “dog poop girl” that she dropped out of university (McCreary 2008).

So, even if you are completely devoid of any forms of technology in your own private life, privacy is still a very real issue.

Additionally, look at current events. The terrible case of kidnapping, rape and murder of Jill Meagher has caused a massive communication surge on Facebook, not all for the good.


The Victoria Police have mentioned that information posted on certain Facebook sites could create bias, and not allow the accused of the crime to have a fair hearing (The Age, 2010). The reason for this ‘bias’ is that it is believed that a jury could not be found to hear the trial as most of the population has heard of such comments on Facebook. Although the information on the social networking site has not been verified, may individuals having read the page may have their opinions tainted by it.

Are we doomed? Will privacy become a historical factor that we look back on with nostalgia?

Burdon & Telford (2010) contend that as the rapid advance of technology continues to grow, more and more detailed definitions of personal information to be protected will develop, which will lead to ever-changing privacy laws. Ultimately, while the ability to infiltrate privacy increases, so must the ability to counter act it.

References:
Burdon M & Telford P, 2010, ‘The Conceptual Basis of Personal Information in Australian Privacy Law’, Murdoch University Electronic Journal of Law, Vol. 17, no 1, Retrieved 21.09.2012, Ebsco Host Database

Debatin B, Lovejoy J, Horn A & Hughes B, 2009, ‘Facebook and Online Privacy: Attitudes, Behaviours, and Unintended Consequences’, Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, Vol 15, Retrieved 21.09.2012, Ebsco Host Database

Kachihi D & Link M, 2009, ‘Too Much Information: Does the Internet Dig Too Deep?’, Journal of Advertising Research, Vol 10, Retrieved 21.09.2012, Ebsco Host Database

Marshall D, 2010, ‘The Specular Economy’, Springer Science & Business Media, Vol: 47, p 498-502, Retrieved 21.09.2012, Ebsco Host Database

Marshall D, 2006, ‘New Media – New Self, The changing power of celebrity’, in D Marshall (ed), The Celebrity Culture Reader, Routledge, New York

McCreary L, 2008, ‘What Was Privacy?’, Harvard Business Review, Retrieved 21.09.2012, Ebsco Host Database

The Age, 2010, Facebook shuts-down Meagher suspect pages, Fairfax Media, Retrieved 03.10.2012, http://www.theage.com.au/technology/technology-news/facebook-shuts-down-meagher-suspect-pages-20121003-26yrd.html

You Tube Clips:

No comments:

Post a Comment